{
  "schema": "oa-mod-closed-form-proof-guide/v2",
  "lesson": {
    "id": "OA-MOD-QF",
    "title": "Recovering operators from energy forms",
    "source": "src/closed-positive-forms.md",
    "reader": "closed-positive-forms.html",
    "mathematical_item_ids": [
      "OA-MOD-QF-01",
      "OA-MOD-QF-02",
      "OA-MOD-QF-03",
      "OA-MOD-QF-04",
      "OA-MOD-QF-05",
      "OA-MOD-QF-06",
      "OA-MOD-QF-07",
      "OA-MOD-QF-08",
      "OA-MOD-QF-09",
      "OA-MOD-QF-10",
      "OA-MOD-QF-11"
    ]
  },
  "source": "src/closed-positive-forms.md",
  "source_sha256": "6a1387411dd13152645cc16d8ed3d6f73988af10b2f9b366b1c14217911202d2",
  "exact_complete_proof_providers": [
    {
      "id": "OA-FND-HS-01",
      "source": "courses/foundations-of-von-neumann-algebras/src/hilbert-spaces-and-compact-operators.md",
      "lines": [
        22,
        83
      ],
      "contract": "Positivity/polarization and Hilbert completion; bounded isometry extension on arbitrary Hilbert spaces.",
      "reader": "https://kokunoyumeto.github.io/open-math-courses/courses/foundations-of-von-neumann-algebras/hilbert-spaces-and-compact-operators.html#oa-fnd-hs-01",
      "license": "CC0-1.0",
      "raw_source_sha256": "c37f79bc01c64ef1198571d05fb5aeb18a80c704afc642ab50f904fd88f62fd5",
      "range_sha256_LF_with_final_newline": "5a58f40a883b44b19a32dce42348ae24781f339aa58794de40ac8fe2c57d7863",
      "verified_at": "2026-10-04T03:27:24.447458+00:00"
    },
    {
      "id": "OA-FND-HS-02",
      "source": "courses/foundations-of-von-neumann-algebras/src/hilbert-spaces-and-compact-operators.md",
      "lines": [
        84,
        115
      ],
      "exact_theorems": "Theorems 2.1, 2.2, 2.3",
      "contract": "Projection, orthogonal double complement and Riesz representation, linear-first, arbitrary H.",
      "reader": "https://kokunoyumeto.github.io/open-math-courses/courses/foundations-of-von-neumann-algebras/hilbert-spaces-and-compact-operators.html#oa-fnd-hs-02",
      "license": "CC0-1.0",
      "raw_source_sha256": "c37f79bc01c64ef1198571d05fb5aeb18a80c704afc642ab50f904fd88f62fd5",
      "range_sha256_LF_with_final_newline": "4da0acf479b6c4c00703ebcff6c184888f9f95c986f66b511007a7f1ec72bc69",
      "verified_at": "2026-10-04T03:27:24.447458+00:00"
    },
    {
      "id": "OA-FND-HS-03",
      "source": "courses/foundations-of-von-neumann-algebras/src/hilbert-spaces-and-compact-operators.md",
      "lines": [
        116,
        142
      ],
      "exact_theorems": "Theorem 3.1 and Corollary 3.2",
      "contract": "Bounded sesquilinear-form representation and adjoints. Rectangular adjoint is the same Riesz proof with target vector fixed; explicit bridge supplied in proposal.",
      "reader": "https://kokunoyumeto.github.io/open-math-courses/courses/foundations-of-von-neumann-algebras/hilbert-spaces-and-compact-operators.html#oa-fnd-hs-03",
      "license": "CC0-1.0",
      "raw_source_sha256": "c37f79bc01c64ef1198571d05fb5aeb18a80c704afc642ab50f904fd88f62fd5",
      "range_sha256_LF_with_final_newline": "737c3933e865d00463cf81242f65ba119fc1419e6ebc4e51f41d6bb043e792a7",
      "verified_at": "2026-10-04T03:27:24.447458+00:00"
    },
    {
      "id": "OA-MOD-BK-01",
      "source": "courses/OA-MOD/src/bounded-operator-kernel.md",
      "lines": [
        9,
        34
      ],
      "contract": "Concrete positivity, kernel square-root identity and closure(range T)=(ker T*)-perp.",
      "reader": "https://kokunoyumeto.github.io/open-math-courses/courses/OA-MOD/bounded-operator-kernel.html#OA-MOD-BK-01",
      "raw_source_sha256": "04e0495ab7ec51fdc6b6f07a5dc835dfa623680103fc9f5bfc0cf30c9204fd3b",
      "range_sha256_LF_with_final_newline": "9ffb23f424a25f12ab166dcce1dcbf3ec98aaf938fc2e90c9ffe32a789346312",
      "verified_at": "2026-10-04T03:27:24.447458+00:00"
    },
    {
      "id": "OA-MOD-BK-07",
      "source": "courses/OA-MOD/src/bounded-operator-kernel.md",
      "lines": [
        322,
        396
      ],
      "specific_lines": [
        372,
        395
      ],
      "contract": "Rectangular bounded polar decomposition C=U|C|=|C*|U; U unitary when C is injective with dense range. Construction uses bounded square roots and extension of an isometry, with no closed-form/unbounded-polar theorem.",
      "reader": "https://kokunoyumeto.github.io/open-math-courses/courses/OA-MOD/bounded-operator-kernel.html#OA-MOD-BK-07",
      "raw_source_sha256": "04e0495ab7ec51fdc6b6f07a5dc835dfa623680103fc9f5bfc0cf30c9204fd3b",
      "range_sha256_LF_with_final_newline": "a9f26b3e6ea01c9ae06068b0de1a9127a72b096ea1614600fdb5f87c30be36f4",
      "verified_at": "2026-10-04T03:27:24.447458+00:00"
    },
    {
      "id": "OA-MOD-SK-04",
      "source": "courses/OA-MOD/src/spectral-calculus-kernel.md",
      "lines": [
        70,
        110
      ],
      "contract": "Bounded Borel calculus, finite vector measures, spectral projections and uniqueness; arbitrary cyclic-sum index.",
      "reader": "https://kokunoyumeto.github.io/open-math-courses/courses/OA-MOD/spectral-calculus-kernel.html#OA-MOD-SK-04",
      "raw_source_sha256": "7a6a51a63cc5a4493d6ff428f2ca9731a57d26219c03207b522d328a69b092e0",
      "range_sha256_LF_with_final_newline": "c59feeb2a0e3aed5c609f7f0224de9f43c1c14a1dc59148a77ccc74ed2f344d2",
      "verified_at": "2026-10-04T03:27:24.447458+00:00"
    },
    {
      "id": "OA-MOD-SK-05",
      "source": "courses/OA-MOD/src/spectral-calculus-kernel.md",
      "lines": [
        112,
        156
      ],
      "contract": "Closedness, dense squared-integral domains, adjoints and self-adjointness for real functions; actual product domains; graph cutoffs.",
      "reader": "https://kokunoyumeto.github.io/open-math-courses/courses/OA-MOD/spectral-calculus-kernel.html#OA-MOD-SK-05",
      "raw_source_sha256": "7a6a51a63cc5a4493d6ff428f2ca9731a57d26219c03207b522d328a69b092e0",
      "range_sha256_LF_with_final_newline": "7ba262113155431a5aebad74ef86149096e58903c09e1d6ab60fb7bd1606b8b9",
      "verified_at": "2026-10-04T03:27:24.447458+00:00"
    },
    {
      "id": "OA-MOD-SK-06",
      "source": "courses/OA-MOD/src/spectral-calculus-kernel.md",
      "lines": [
        158,
        207
      ],
      "contract": "Existence and uniqueness of arbitrary self-adjoint spectral resolution via Cayley transform; positive support.",
      "reader": "https://kokunoyumeto.github.io/open-math-courses/courses/OA-MOD/spectral-calculus-kernel.html#OA-MOD-SK-06",
      "raw_source_sha256": "7a6a51a63cc5a4493d6ff428f2ca9731a57d26219c03207b522d328a69b092e0",
      "range_sha256_LF_with_final_newline": "f6e3282e4d4d32a36cdc9ae898f9a99a120597052731c619d48ea1f8c37b54e9",
      "verified_at": "2026-10-04T03:27:24.447458+00:00"
    },
    {
      "id": "OA-MOD-SK-07",
      "source": "courses/OA-MOD/src/spectral-calculus-kernel.md",
      "lines": [
        209,
        261
      ],
      "contract": "Changes of variable; unique positive square root; exact form pairing; inverse domains equal actual ranges; logarithms and powers.",
      "reader": "https://kokunoyumeto.github.io/open-math-courses/courses/OA-MOD/spectral-calculus-kernel.html#OA-MOD-SK-07",
      "raw_source_sha256": "7a6a51a63cc5a4493d6ff428f2ca9731a57d26219c03207b522d328a69b092e0",
      "range_sha256_LF_with_final_newline": "aebaf6ea4ab8152fed6e14139c54c69c847d8ec98861a26dda7112adbbc35a7e",
      "verified_at": "2026-10-04T03:27:24.447458+00:00"
    },
    {
      "id": "OA-MOD-SK-08",
      "source": "courses/OA-MOD/src/spectral-calculus-kernel.md",
      "lines": [
        263,
        288
      ],
      "contract": "Unitary/antiunitary transport with domains, reduction and bounded Borel membership/affiliation.",
      "reader": "https://kokunoyumeto.github.io/open-math-courses/courses/OA-MOD/spectral-calculus-kernel.html#OA-MOD-SK-08",
      "raw_source_sha256": "7a6a51a63cc5a4493d6ff428f2ca9731a57d26219c03207b522d328a69b092e0",
      "range_sha256_LF_with_final_newline": "1c0f3c225b2013caad735c74bd0c9c3b4faf18e02d034c2d92b7bdca3731584e",
      "verified_at": "2026-10-04T03:27:24.447458+00:00"
    },
    {
      "id": "OA-MOD-SK-09",
      "source": "courses/OA-MOD/src/spectral-calculus-kernel.md",
      "lines": [
        290,
        357
      ],
      "specific_lines": [
        290,
        301
      ],
      "contract": "Scalar spectral DCT/cutoffs and strong continuous functional-calculus convergence on bounded self-adjoint nets. Line 301 supplies the Bernstein proof of compact-interval polynomial approximation.",
      "reader": "https://kokunoyumeto.github.io/open-math-courses/courses/OA-MOD/spectral-calculus-kernel.html#OA-MOD-SK-09",
      "raw_source_sha256": "7a6a51a63cc5a4493d6ff428f2ca9731a57d26219c03207b522d328a69b092e0",
      "range_sha256_LF_with_final_newline": "0f00291b170a3f8de1d403e9168aae5144286eee6b32e6c35dfb42b89b42ee7f",
      "verified_at": "2026-10-04T03:27:24.447458+00:00"
    },
    {
      "id": "MEASURE-TOOLS-MCT-DCT",
      "source": "courses/harmonic-analysis-on-locally-compact-groups/src/measure-and-hilbert-space-tools.md",
      "lines": [
        36,
        69
      ],
      "exact_theorems": "Theorem 2.1 (48–57), Theorem 2.2 (59–69)",
      "contract": "Sequential monotone and real/complex dominated convergence for arbitrary measures; use on finite scalar spectral measures. No general net DCT.",
      "reader": "https://kokunoyumeto.github.io/open-math-courses/courses/harmonic-analysis-on-locally-compact-groups/reader/measure-and-hilbert-space-tools.html#2-integration-and-convergence-without-countability-assumptions",
      "license": "CC0-1.0",
      "raw_source_sha256": "ee22f2f44dd2c089b2bfb10d25fd5b36ebd9d7c245ea3206a1abb71e393e2e12",
      "range_sha256_LF_with_final_newline": "c7f587e9e93f437180c96b6cf12e9f0cd87cbe998db615ed029d251fd7a5343c",
      "verified_at": "2026-10-04T03:27:24.447458+00:00"
    },
    {
      "id": "OA-MOD-BK-02",
      "source": "courses/OA-MOD/src/bounded-operator-kernel.md",
      "lines": [
        35,
        117
      ],
      "contract": "Bicommutant theorem; required only for QF-04 optional algebra application.",
      "reader": "https://kokunoyumeto.github.io/open-math-courses/courses/OA-MOD/bounded-operator-kernel.html#OA-MOD-BK-02",
      "raw_source_sha256": "04e0495ab7ec51fdc6b6f07a5dc835dfa623680103fc9f5bfc0cf30c9204fd3b",
      "range_sha256_LF_with_final_newline": "241587d8fd8f6eaf7aa2acd3f4abe2e8edc33d881b4e28ac4c49bbda2af34a73",
      "verified_at": "2026-10-04T03:27:24.447458+00:00"
    },
    {
      "id": "OA-MOD-BK-08",
      "source": "courses/OA-MOD/src/bounded-operator-kernel.md",
      "lines": [
        397,
        410
      ],
      "contract": "Four-unitary linear span and unitary commutation test; only optional algebra application.",
      "reader": "https://kokunoyumeto.github.io/open-math-courses/courses/OA-MOD/bounded-operator-kernel.html#OA-MOD-BK-08",
      "raw_source_sha256": "04e0495ab7ec51fdc6b6f07a5dc835dfa623680103fc9f5bfc0cf30c9204fd3b",
      "range_sha256_LF_with_final_newline": "066ed5856199bcdc9bc094cb9c2a0dd8f6a2c91be4142775ee358498be69e4d0",
      "verified_at": "2026-10-04T03:27:24.447458+00:00"
    },
    {
      "id": "OA-FND-HB-01",
      "source": "courses/foundations-of-von-neumann-algebras/src/hahn-banach-baire-and-the-basic-theorems-on-banach-spaces.md",
      "lines": [
        30,
        46
      ],
      "exact_theorems": "Theorem 1.1",
      "contract": "Zorn maximal principle from choice, transitive input to SK-03. QF does not use a new Hahn–Banach assumption.",
      "reader": "https://kokunoyumeto.github.io/open-math-courses/courses/foundations-of-von-neumann-algebras/hahn-banach-baire-and-the-basic-theorems-on-banach-spaces.html#oa-fnd-hb-01",
      "license": "CC0-1.0",
      "raw_source_sha256": "f09b763b00c87141faac24be5c8d4a4760c3439085288bcdb56263731281e850",
      "range_sha256_LF_with_final_newline": "2e5ef455fd837f8dcc2a87e1868ecd8a21c081927f9bae52a7ad313a424e1d70",
      "verified_at": "2026-10-04T03:27:24.447458+00:00"
    }
  ],
  "foundation_contracts": {
    "OA-MOD-DEP-HILBERT": [
      "OA-MOD-OPEN-HILBERT-PROJECTION",
      "OA-MOD-OPEN-HILBERT-RIESZ",
      "OA-MOD-OPEN-HILBERT-BOUNDED-FORM",
      "OA-MOD-OPEN-HILBERT-COMPLETION",
      "OA-MOD-OPEN-HILBERT-ADJOINT"
    ],
    "OA-MOD-DEP-SPECTRAL": [
      "OA-MOD-BK-07",
      "OA-MOD-SK-04",
      "OA-MOD-SK-05",
      "OA-MOD-SK-06",
      "OA-MOD-SK-07",
      "OA-MOD-SK-08",
      "OA-MOD-SK-09"
    ]
  },
  "noncircularity": {
    "order": [
      "HS completion/Riesz/projections/adjoints and bounded continuous calculus",
      "BK-07 bounded rectangular/left polar decomposition; SK-02–09 spectral construction (HB maximal principle and scalar proofs are transitive inputs)",
      "QF-03 representation and QF-10 Problem 1 self-adjointness of T*T",
      "TC-07 closed-involution form",
      "TC-08 unbounded conjugate-linear polar factorization"
    ],
    "forbidden_back_edges": [
      "QF-03 must not import TC-08, RD-02 or a general unbounded-polar theorem.",
      "QF-03 must not take QF-10's conclusion that T*T is self-adjoint as an input.",
      "Sebestyén–Tarcsay's Q*Q method is a human theorem comparison, not the current construction mechanism."
    ],
    "cp_role": "The now-public concrete-predual foundation is not a direct prerequisite for QF."
  },
  "human_free_primary_comparisons": [
    {
      "authors": "Zoltán Sebestyén and Zsigmond Tarcsay",
      "title": "Basic representation theorems of forms",
      "version": "arXiv:2505.09588v1, 14 May 2025",
      "url": "https://arxiv.org/pdf/2505.09588v1",
      "html": "https://arxiv.org/html/2505.09588v1",
      "raw_pdf_sha256": "87861af02617564e661e7c188c02fec6e5e3b0e1abf5f0759c42500da78d25c8",
      "bytes": 304811,
      "retrieved_at": "2026-10-04T02:47:08.6591161Z",
      "read_loci": [
        "Section 2 setup and Lemma 2.1 with proof, printed pp.2–3",
        "Corollary 2.7 with proof, printed p.7 (PDF page 7); web parsed lines 423–443"
      ],
      "correspondence": "Dense closed nonnegative forms, exact square-root domain and bounded-form-functional operator-domain criterion agree with QF-03 on arbitrary real or complex Hilbert spaces.",
      "boundary": "Their proof invokes closed Q*Q theory. QF independently proves representation from bounded inclusion and spectral calculus; QF-10 derives T*T afterward. This source is a comparator, never a back-edge construction input.",
      "reuse": "External human research reading only; no text, PDF or human structured component imported."
    },
    {
      "authors": "Barry Simon",
      "title": "A canonical decomposition for quadratic forms with applications to monotone convergence theorems",
      "publication": "Journal of Functional Analysis 28 (1978), 377–385",
      "url": "https://math.caltech.edu/SimonPapers/81.pdf",
      "doi": "10.1016/0022-1236(78)90094-0",
      "raw_pdf_sha256": "6bedf6ed356c6d4bff14477e4d7437a6f20b3c467ea792af724aae637bc14d60",
      "bytes": 473712,
      "retrieved_at": "2026-10-04T02:47:11.4532397Z",
      "read_loci": [
        "Section 1 finite-energy definition and form order, pp.377–379",
        "Theorem 3.1 with proof, p.382 (PDF page 6)",
        "Section 4 and Theorem 4.1, pp.383–384 (PDF pages 7–8)"
      ],
      "correspondence": "Theorem 3.1 gives increasing sequential closed-form convergence under a closed upper bound. Theorem 4.1 extends to nondense forms and removes that upper bound; resolvents vanish on the perpendicular complement.",
      "boundary": "The human paper proves sequential versions. QF-06–08 retain their own written directed-net and locally uniform power arguments. Do not claim Simon proves the net statement or use his Theorem 4.2 pointer to another book as a complete standalone proof provider.",
      "reuse": "External human research reading only; no PDF or text redistributed."
    }
  ],
  "scope": "Closed-form foundations on arbitrary Hilbert spaces, directed finite-energy form limits and locally uniform imaginary powers; optional bounded-algebra affiliation inputs specified separately",
  "scalar_convergence_scope": "Only sequential scalar MCT/DCT; directed form/resolvent limits proved by their own energy estimates",
  "source_notice": "closed-form-source-history.json",
  "full_programme_bodies_record": "programme-proof-bodies.json",
  "review_credit": "GPT-6 Astra (OpenAI), Ultra; AI review, not formal verification."
}